A CNC prototype has passed the assembly check, and the next step is a small repeat batch.
At this point, the most important question is not whether the prototype looked acceptable. It is:
Which drawing and CAD files now control production?
If the prototype was manufactured and accepted without any design change, the original files may still be valid. If the prototype was altered during testing, the next batch should not be released until those changes have been added to the approved manufacturing files.
The physical prototype can support the engineering review, but it should not become an undocumented substitute for the drawing.
First Determine Whether the Prototype Design Changed
Before requesting the repeat batch, place the project into one of three conditions.
| Required action before the repeat batch |
|---|
The prototype was accepted without any design change | Confirm in writing that the original drawing and STEP file remain valid |
The design was revised after testing | Submit the approved revised drawing and matching STEP file |
The physical prototype was modified, but the files were not updated | Do not release the batch yet; update and approve the manufacturing files first |
This decision should be made by the customer’s engineering team. YSBK can identify conflicting or incomplete information during quotation review, but it does not decide whether a temporary prototype adjustment should become part of the customer’s design.
When the Files Have Not Changed
The customer does not need to resend the same complete file package for every repeat order.
If the drawing and STEP model used for the prototype remain unchanged, YSBK can continue using those files after receiving written confirmation by email.
The confirmation should identify:
- The controlling drawing revision;
- The applicable CAD or STEP revision, where used;
- The repeat-batch quantity;
- Confirmation that no design change has been made.
A practical email instruction would be:
Please use the previously supplied drawing and STEP file for Part [part number], Revision [revision], as the manufacturing basis for this repeat order of [quantity] parts. No design changes have been made since the prototype order.
This is more reliable than a message such as “make another 20 like the sample.” It connects the new order to a specific controlled file set instead of asking the supplier to interpret a physical part.
If the original file names do not clearly identify the revision, include enough information in the email to distinguish the approved files from obsolete versions.
A Hand-Modified Prototype Does Not Control Production
Prototype fitting sometimes reveals a change that was not visible during the drawing review.
An engineer may grind an edge for clearance, open a hole during assembly or polish a contact area to improve movement. These adjustments can help identify what the design needs, but they are not repeatable manufacturing instructions by themselves.
YSBK will not use a hand-modified prototype as the sole basis for a production batch.
There are several reasons for this:
- The amount of material removed may not have been recorded;
- The adjusted geometry may not have a defined tolerance;
- The change may affect a mating feature or another dimension;
- The physical sample may not show which surfaces were intentionally changed;
- The adjustment may have been temporary and not approved as a design revision.
A photograph of the modified area can help explain the issue, but a photograph without controlled dimensions does not define the production geometry.
If the adjusted condition is required on the repeat parts, the customer should measure and evaluate the change, update the drawing and CAD model, and formally approve the new revision.
The engineering rule is simple:
If a prototype change must be repeated, it must appear in the approved manufacturing files.
The Revised Drawing and STEP File Must Represent the Same Design
When a design change has been approved, send both the revised drawing and the corresponding STEP file.
The two files perform different jobs. The STEP model normally communicates the part geometry, while the drawing may define tolerances, threads, material condition, surface requirements and inspection notes that are not fully contained in the model.
Problems arise when the files represent different design states—for example:
- The drawing shows a revised hole location, but the STEP model still contains the prototype geometry;
- A clearance was added to the model but not dimensioned on the drawing;
- The drawing revision changed, while an older STEP file remained attached to the RFQ;
- A manually modified feature appears only in a photograph.
YSBK’s DFM & Quotation Engineer can flag an apparent conflict during review, but the customer must confirm which design is approved.
For the broader requirements of a complete manufacturing package, refer to the Build-to-Print Manufacturing Guide. The present article only addresses the release of files after prototype evaluation. Production Release and Inspection Records Are Separate Decisions
Approving the manufacturing files does not automatically define which inspection documents must accompany the batch.
YSBK inspects parts against the agreed drawing requirements. However, first-piece photographs, recorded critical dimensions and formatted inspection sheets are not included automatically with every repeat order.
If these deliverables are needed, specify them during the RFQ:
- Which dimensions or features require a recorded result;
- How many parts require recorded measurements;
- Whether first-piece photographs are required;
- Which views or features the photographs should show;
- The required record format;
- Whether customer confirmation is required before the remaining quantity proceeds.
The agreed scope should be included in the quotation or order requirements.
For suitable features, YSBK can provide selected critical-dimension records using basic workshop measuring tools such as calipers, micrometers, depth gauges and height gauges. The record may be handwritten or prepared in an Excel format, depending on the agreed scope.
YSBK does not provide an in-house CMM report, a formal AS9102 FAI report or a full-dimensional inspection package as a default service.
If photographs or measurement records were not agreed during the RFQ, YSBK will not automatically attach a complete first-piece report to the shipment.
Use a Short File-Release Check Before Ordering
Before sending the repeat-batch RFQ, confirm the following:
- Which drawing revision controls production?
- Which STEP or CAD file matches that revision?
- Has the design changed since the prototype was manufactured?
- Was the prototype modified manually during testing?
- Have all required changes been added to the approved files?
- What quantity is required for the repeat batch?
- Are first-piece photographs or recorded dimensions required?
- Have those inspection deliverables been included in the RFQ?
This check is intentionally shorter than a complete manufacturing RFQ checklist. Its purpose is to answer one question: whether the prototype file set is ready to control the next batch.
Send the Released Files for Manufacturing Review
If the prototype was accepted without changes, email YSBK with the part number, controlling revision and repeat quantity. Confirm that the previously supplied drawing and STEP file should remain the manufacturing basis.
If the prototype design changed, send the approved revised drawing and matching STEP model.
If the only record of the change is a hand-modified physical sample, update the manufacturing files before releasing the batch. YSBK will not reconstruct the final production geometry from the modified sample alone.
FAQ
Must I resend the same drawing and STEP file for every repeat order?
No. If the design and revision remain unchanged, you can confirm by email that YSBK should continue using the previously supplied files. Include the part number, revision and required quantity.
What happens if the prototype was modified during assembly?
The physical modification cannot be transferred directly into repeat production. If the change is required, the customer must update and approve the drawing and matching CAD file before the batch is manufactured.
Is a photograph enough to define a prototype modification?
A photograph can help explain the location and purpose of a change, but it does not replace controlled dimensions, tolerances and approved manufacturing files.
Are first-piece photographs and measurement records included automatically?
No. The required features, photographs, sampling quantity and record format must be agreed during the RFQ and included in the quotation or order scope.
Can YSBK create the revised production drawing from the modified sample?
No. YSBK manufactures from customer-approved drawings and CAD files. A hand-modified sample is not accepted as the sole source for reconstructing the production design.